from your description, I do not think the arrowhead seal you have is correct.
When I rebuilt my car I searched all over the UK without satisfaction.
The common seals LOOK alright but in fact are all just slightly fatter!
The correct, in every detail, seal is only available from Clarke Restorations
in the USA. He does MGA stuff mainly, but has tooled some Magnette items - arrowhead section also correct original shape plated cable/pipe clips.
His address is listed on this web site. I contact him via interweb.